Thursday, October 29, 2026

FINISHED READING - Notes On Nationalism by George Orwell



' Every nationalist is haunted by the belief that the past can be altered.'

This pocket book of three essays by Orwell; Notes on Nationalism; Anti-Semitism in Britain; The Sporting Spirit, were all written in 1945, at a point near the end of the war. And Orwell is minded to reflect on the prevalence of nationalism generally within the UK itself, than bask in the unwarranted superiority of being the victor over Nazi fascism.

'The general uncertainty as to what is really happening makes it easier to cling to lunatic beliefs'

Reading it over eighty years later, it's a mixture of recognising some of the nationalistic tropes, but bound up with concerns very particular to the time, and what became the search for a post war consensus - of never again. But what Orwell says time after time here, is that we have to examine our own residual tendencies towards xenophobia, nationalism, racism and the othering of minorities. Ridding ourselves of the Nazi threat, was not the end of all that, would that it were. 

So, does Orwell have anything to say, that might be useful for us to here now? He starts, as one should, by defining his terms.

By 'nationalism' I mean...the habit of assuming human beings can be classified like insects...confidently labelled 'good' and 'bad'...the habit of identifying oneself with a single nation or other unit, placing it beyond good and evil and recognising no other duty than that of advancing its interests. Nationalism is not to be confused with patriotism.'

He then proceeds to identify three particular characteristics.
First, an obsession with cultural superiority and the execution of power and prestige.
Second, an indifference in not seeing the reality of different sets of facts as being similar.

'Actions are held to be good or bad, not on their own merit but according to who does them, and there is almost no kind of outrage...which does not change its moral colour when it is committed by 'our' side.'

Thirdly,  an instability is often built in to the nationalistic frames of reference. The most nationalistic of leaders are often not from the country they are extolling the virtues of, and their allegiances can quickly shift from approval to condemnation. Hitler being the classic example. Nazism and extreme Zionism shared very similar ideological foundations, but Hitler, nonetheless took against the Jews.

Orwell then explores three types of Nationalism, which are not separate and discreet from each other, and can cross blend. 

Positive Nationalism - such as that propounded by what we would now call the Far Right of the Tory Party, or Reform - What Orwell calls Celtic Nationalism, but we would see as the SNP or Plaid Cymru today - and finally Zionism. All contain ideas which are the seeds of ideals for an innate and self righteous superiority.

Transferred Nationalism - where particular individual gripes become elevated into nationalistic concerns, such as Communism, Political Catholicism, Feelings about one's colour or class, Pacifism. To which I might add Woke Culture Wars and Immigration.

Negative Nationalism - where the intelligentsia, or elites take a derisively hostile attitude towards something, such as a habitual Anglophobia towards anything Britain does. - a similar attitude of Anti-semitism - An anarchistic approach towards Communism, that Orwell labels Trotskyism. 

Almost embarrassed by the level of his own over simplification of the issue, he then concludes by recognising the complexity:-

' One has no right to assume everyone, or even every intellectual, is infected by nationalism. Secondly, nationalism can be intermittent and limited. An intelligent man may half-succumb to a belief which attracts him but which he knows to be absurd, and he may keep it out of his mind for long periods, only reverting to it in moments of anger or sentimentality, or where he is certain that no important issue is involved.  Thirdly, a nationalistic creed may be adopted in good faith from non-nationalist motives. Fourthly, several kinds of nationalism, even kinds that cancel out, can coexist in the same person.'

Essentially Orwell is stating that we are all capable of evincing strong nationalistic tendencies, that it does quite often depend upon the conditions we find ourselves in. And I can observe myself making internal judgements about who Reform voters or flag shaggers are, and I habitually imagine poorer working class people who 'don't know any better' which is a middle class way of implying they are ignorant. However, if I was to find myself in straightened economic circumstances, where would my anger and frustration be directed?. Would it locate someone or something to blame, what or who would that be? If you found yourself financially struggling how would you maintain your sense of dignity or self worth?

'The point is that as soon as fear, hatred, jealousy and power worship are involved, the sense of reality becomes unhinged... even if one admits in an intellectual sense that it is unjustified - still one cannot feel that it is wrong. Loyalty is involved, and so pity ceases to function.''

In the end Orwell turns the focus back upon ourselves. Nationalist viewpoints too easily locate the source of all our problems external to us. Fighting nationalism externally means recognising this tendency within ourselves, so we can come from a point of empathy, and not entirely driven by a consciously self-cultivated enmity.

' As for the nationalistic loves and hatreds that I have spoken of, they are part of the makeup of most of us, whether we like it or not. Whether it is possible to get rid of them I do not know, but I do believe that it is possible to struggle against them, and that this is essentially a moral effort. 

It is a question first of all of discovering what one really is, what one's own feelings are, and then making allowance for the inevitable bias.'

As an essay, Notes on Nationalism does have a world view that is very much of its time. So, yeah, it is a bit dated in the examples he gives. But its essential moral thrust is still quite powerfully expressed. to start from your own home, before you are tempted to start throwing stones at another person's.


CARROT REVIEW - 4/8 




No comments: